Search Lodges in Long Island

"The Starlight is absolutely perfect. The location is great—close to everything you need/want . The staff is incredibly welcoming and attentive. The cleanliness and amenities are outstanding, with spotless rooms. Overall, a fantastic experience I highly recommend for a staycation or a trip"

"We have stayed at the Montauk Manor for the holidays many times and find it friendly, peaceful and comfortable."

"The room was super comfortable and well designed for the limited space available - also quiet, so we slept great. The only elevator broke down while we were there, and we had to climb 4 flights of stairs a few times to reach our 5th floor room. (We saw others who had to carry very heavy luggage down the stairs). The surrounding area feels quite safe but is a bit dark and dingy. The hotel no longer offers parking, and the nearby options are sketchy, so we don’t recommend it if you’re driving...