Independent in Upper Matecumbe Key

"We thoroughly enjoyed the quietness of the property. The beautiful sunrises and tropical vibe of Amara Cay was stunning. We definitely plan on visiting again."

"Check-in procedures are slow and although most were being offered sparkling wine, we were not. Additional, our room was not ready at the allotted check-in time. No explanation or retribution was offered. Skip the Asian restaurant upstairs. The sushi was horrible and the staff unfriendly and hurried. Despite the negative, the property is beautifully kept and the ambiance is wonderful. The spa was great! Both my husband and I thought highly of our massage therapists. Parking is easy if you...

"Very good "

"Awesome place to stay in islamorada. Quiet private beach for relaxation"

"The property advertises fishing but on an active day you got paddle boards in the water, snorkeling , lacking , also people trying to catch the sunset, doesn’t leave a lot of room for the person fishing off the pier! "

"It was a lovely stay for a wedding, calm and peaceful and helpful, friendly staff, clean and well-kept environment."

"excellent location for exploring islamorada large property great pool "

"Absolutely amazing place. Can't wait to go back. Highly recommend it."