Benchmark in Islamorada

"Beautiful property and excellent customer service."

"Good value for the money. Enjoyed using the kayaks and paddle boards. Friendly staff. Very good location on the water."

"Awesome place to stay in islamorada. Quiet private beach for relaxation"

"We thoroughly enjoyed the quietness of the property. The beautiful sunrises and tropical vibe of Amara Cay was stunning. We definitely plan on visiting again."

"Our 3 night stay was wonderful!!! The staff was so nice and checkin was super fast!! Our room looked just like the pictures on the website. Everything was clean and updated. Beds were so comfortable!! The grounds were very nice and clean. One of the highlights of our stay was Bonnie the cat!! She was the sweetest little kitty!!! Pool was very nice and the beach area was beautiful!! If you’re looking nice relaxing stay then this is the place!!! Can’t wait to visit again!!!!"

"excellent location for exploring islamorada large property great pool "

"Highly recommend for families! Great property and amenities. Heated pool and good food! "

"So many amenities to be used here!! Bikes, paddle boarding, kayaking, swimming, and so much more!! It was a nice area!!"

"Cool fun place"